Shopping for LED shop lights, garage lights or commercial fixtures, you'll run into two kinds: integrated LED fixtures, where the LEDs are built into the fixture, and LED-ready (tube-based) fixtures, where the fixture holds replaceable LED tubes. Neither one is "better" across the board. They solve different problems, and the right pick depends on the room, who maintains it, and whether you already have fixtures on the ceiling. Here's the 2026 version of the comparison, kept short.
The quick difference
- Integrated LED: the light source is LED boards or strips mounted inside the fixture. There's no bulb to change. You buy one complete unit, wire it in, and it's done.
- LED-ready (tube): the fixture has sockets (tombstones) and takes standard LED tubes, like 4 ft T8 tubes. When a tube wears out or you want a different color, you swap the tube and keep the fixture.
When integrated LED makes sense
- New installs and harsh spaces. Sealed fixtures are a natural fit for garages, carports, car washes, barns, cold storage and anywhere damp or dusty. Orilis vapor tight fixtures are integrated LED with a gasketed, IP65-rated polycarbonate housing (here's what IP65 means).
- Fewer loose parts. No tubes to buy separately, no sockets to wire. It's one fixture with Line, Neutral and Ground leads.
- Fixed output, chosen up front. The color temperature and lumens are set at the factory, so pick carefully. Orilis vapor tight fixtures come in 2 ft (36W, 3,600 lumens) and 4 ft (72W, 8,000 lumens), each in 4500K or 6500K.
- The trade-off: when the LEDs eventually reach end of life, you're usually replacing the light engine or the whole fixture, not a bulb. (The Orilis 4 ft vapor tight uses detachable LED strips.)
When LED-ready (tubes) makes sense
- You already have fluorescent fixtures. Most troffers, strip lights and shop lights can keep their housings. Convert them once, and from then on they take LED tubes. The Orilis 4-light retrofit kit includes four 22W double-ended tubes, eight non-shunted lamp holders, loop and connecting wires and wire nuts, enough for one 4-lamp or two 2-lamp fixtures.
- Easy replacements later. 4 ft T8 is one of the most common tube sizes around. In a fixture already wired for double-ended tubes, replacing a tube is a quarter-turn job.
- Change your mind on color. Want a cooler or warmer look? Change the tubes, not the fixture. Orilis double-ended T8 tubes are 22W, about 3,000 lumens each, frosted, in 4500K, 5000K or 6500K.
- The trade-off: the first conversion takes more work. Double-ended (ballast bypass) tubes need the ballast removed and the sockets wired Line on one end and Neutral on the other (see ballast bypass vs plug-and-play and single-ended vs double-ended).
Side by side
| Integrated LED | LED-ready (tubes) | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | New installs, damp or dusty areas | Upgrading fixtures you already have |
| Setup | Mount and wire one unit | One-time rewire, then insert tubes |
| Changing color later | Not possible | Swap tubes |
| When the light wears out | Replace strips or fixture | Replace a tube |
| Orilis option | 2 ft or 4 ft vapor tight, 4500K or 6500K | Double-ended T8 tubes or the 4-light kit |
Three questions to decide
- Is there a fixture there now, and is it in good shape? Yes: converting it to LED tubes is usually the least waste. No (or it's rusted, cracked or missing): go integrated.
- Is the spot wet, dusty or hosed down? A sealed vapor tight fixture is the safer bet.
- Who changes the lights? If nobody wants to touch it for years, integrated keeps it simple. If you like stocking one spare tube for the whole building, tubes win.
Safety first: turn the breaker off and confirm with a voltage tester before opening any fixture, use non-shunted sockets for double-ended tubes, and label converted fixtures. If you're unsure, consult a licensed electrician.
Still deciding?
Tell us what's on your ceiling now and where it's going, and we'll point you to the right fit. Browse double-ended LED tubes, the 4-light retrofit kit or vapor tight fixtures, or call us at 1-407-900-9745.
